Some myths have a little truth behind them, while others are simply misunderstandings that have been repeated over time.
So, let's put five of the most common cigar myths to the test and separate fact from fiction.
Myth 1: You Should Inhale Cigar Smoke
BUSTED!
Unlike cigarettes, cigars are traditionally enjoyed by drawing the smoke into the mouth, appreciating the flavours and aromas before gently releasing it. Inhaling isn't necessary to experience the character of a cigar.
In fact, most experienced cigar smokers avoid inhaling altogether. However, this doesn't make cigar smoking safe. Cigar smoke contains harmful chemicals, and exposure can still cause serious health problems, even without inhaling.
Myth 2: Darker Wrappers Mean Stronger Cigars
BUSTED!
But that's not necessarily the case.
A cigar's wrapper colour doesn't determine its overall strength. Darker wrappers, such as Maduro, can often contribute sweeter, richer or more chocolatey flavour characteristics, but the strength of a cigar depends on several factors, including the tobacco varieties used in the filler and binder.
I've smoked plenty of dark-wrapped cigars that were surprisingly mild, and lighter-wrapped cigars that packed considerably more punch.
The best way to understand a cigar's strength is to look at its blend and try it for yourself, rather than judging it by appearance alone.
Myth 3: Cuban Cigars Are Always Better
BUSTED!
However, that doesn't automatically make every Cuban cigar better than its New World counterparts.
Countries such as Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic and Honduras produce some exceptional cigars, with experienced rollers, carefully aged tobacco and blends that offer something entirely different.
Brands such as Davidoff, My Father, Drew Estate and Foundation Cigars have all helped demonstrate just how diverse the world of cigars can be.
Personally, I think one of the best things about cigar smoking is discovering new brands and blends. Limiting yourself to Cuban cigars means potentially missing out on some fantastic smokes.
Ultimately, quality comes down to craftsmanship, tobacco and personal preference, not simply the country of origin.
Myth 4: Cigars Don't Go Off
BUSTED!
One of the biggest mistakes a cigar smoker can make is assuming that cigars will remain in perfect condition regardless of how they're stored.
Humidity plays a crucial role in maintaining a cigar's condition. Too little humidity can cause the wrapper to dry out, become brittle and potentially crack. Too much humidity can lead to poor combustion and increase the risk of mould.
A properly maintained humidor generally aims for around 65-70% relative humidity, although personal preferences can vary.
It's also worth remembering that cigars can continue to develop with age when stored correctly. Some benefit from additional ageing, allowing their flavours to evolve and become more integrated.
However, ageing doesn't mean a cigar will improve indefinitely. Eventually, tobacco can lose some of its character, so proper storage and sensible ageing are essential.
Myth 5: The Bigger the Cigar, the Stronger the Smoke
BUSTED!
A common misconception is that a larger cigar will automatically deliver a stronger smoking experience. In reality, cigar size and strength are two very different things.
The dimensions of a cigar are measured using its length and ring gauge. These influence how the cigar burns, how much smoke it produces and how long it takes to smoke.
A larger ring gauge can also allow a blender to incorporate different proportions of filler tobacco, potentially creating a different flavour profile.
However, a long Churchill isn't necessarily stronger than a small Petit Corona. A cigar's strength is determined by its tobacco blend, not simply its physical dimensions.
I've had smaller cigars that delivered considerably more strength than some of the largest cigars I've smoked.
So, next time you're choosing a cigar, don't assume bigger means stronger. Consider the blend, strength and smoking time instead.
Final Thoughts
Whether you prefer a mild Cuban cigar, a full-bodied Nicaraguan blend or something completely different, there's always something new to discover.
And remember, the best cigar isn't necessarily the biggest, darkest or most expensive. It's the one that matches your own preferences.
Written by Lewis Hearn




