Displaying 1 to 6 (of 38 reviews)
Result Pages: 1
Date Added: Friday 03 June, 2016
Reviewed by Stuart Dixon (December 2005)
Last June (2004), whilst working in York, I tracked down the local cigar emporium in the centre of town. This small and well-stocked tobacconist provided 30-minutes worth of "Ooohs" and "Ahhs" as I pressed my nose against the glass door of the walk-in humidor.
I decided immediately upon seeing them that one of the (then) newly-released Montecristo Edmundo's should grace my humidor with its presence, and so picked out the best example.
Substantial in girth, the cigar is dressed in a mid-brown, sheeny wrapper. Solid the entire length, there is a certain toothiness about it, veins evident from top to bottom, and it's double-capped.
It is excellently balanced and feels exceptional in the hand. On the nose, there is leather and fruit, and some pepper to the lips.
It is altogether a very good-looking cigar.
I did read that the cigar was a tad "green" back in the summer of 04 and that it required between 6 months and 3 years to age. I put this single onto the bottom shelf of the humidor and tried to forget about it.
A year later, a trip to London with the Mrs, and a visit to Dick's Bar in the Atlantic Bar and Grill in Piccadilly in July (oh, yes, I am aware how this must look, but it was true!), seemed like the fitting occasion to smoke this majestic cigar.
In the art deco splendour, with a Havana Club on the table in front of me, I pulled it out and began the ritual. It took two matches to toast the foot, the girth being so substantial, but I was in no hurry. I then lit the cigar proper and noted the toasted woodiness that wafted into the room.
The opening draws were some of the very best I've had from any cigar. The pull was just excellent, producing bountiful amounts of thick aromatic smoke which were grandly exhaled towards the starry ceiling of the bar.
The flavours were light - sharp cedar and spices, peppery and crisp.
In the hand, the Edmundo feels just superb - significant, ample and generous all spring to mind - and it looks like a serious cigar. It is particularly imposing in its first inch or so, when it still has that square ash.
Strength-wise, it is a gentle-giant and certainly no cigar beginner should be put off by this one. I found it quite mild, perhaps entering the medium spectrum in its latter stages.
The burn was a little disappointing - it quickly became ragged and required correction - and the ash was initially good and square, but later coned, spoiling the "cut" of the cigar, but, these minor gripes aside, I enjoyed the smoke immensely.
Into the final third, the cigar began to go out. I re-lit it once, but some bitterness was evident and I finally dropped it in a Piccadilly gutter, a glamorous end for any Cuban cigar.
They are perhaps young and fresh still, but age can only add to their quality. This is - and will be - something a bit special. I found this review to be much too wordy for my tastes. I understand that surroundings can play a big part of smoking a special cigar but I would have preferred to have heard more about the cigar and less about the author's surroundings. There was really only the one, one-sentence paragraph that described the actual flavours o! f the cigar. And while the Edmundo is a cigar that I would still like to try, this review did not increase my desire much.
Reviewed by: ScottyJ
Score: 7 out of 10 (Would have been a 6 if I didn't think the author was really trying.)
I like this review! It read like a story that drew the reader in. I liked the way he/she described the characteristics I want to know about, smoke volume and aroma, draw, weight, ash. Hints of "cherry" and "hickory bark" that are so prevalent in other reviews I can do without. I will try this cigar some day - because of this review.
Reviewed by: Darry Rose
Score: 9 out of 10
Written in more of a formal style, I liked the use of visual imagery but it did not enhance the description of the cigar and took focus away from the subject at hand. I did like description of the burn qualities of the cigar ..I could visualize exactly what was happening.
Reviewed by: Chris Cacciotti
Score: 6 out of 10
OVERALL SCORE: 22/30Rating: [4 of 5 Stars!]
Date Added: Sunday 22 May, 2016
My last Cristo was a Petit No.2 which I loved. Surprisingly the Edmundo I am smoking as we speak is falling way short of the Petit No.2. The main taste sensation I am experiencing is very very sweet and one dimensional. he burn of the first half was erratic enough to be annoying. A one off? I don't know.If this is a fair comparison of the two then count me in for the Petit No.2 every time. Disappointing considering all of the glowing reviews and the fact that the Edmundo is about £2 more expensive!Rating: [3 of 5 Stars!]
Date Added: Tuesday 19 May, 2015
Absolutely lovely smoke. Perfect construction and very good draw. Plenty of smoke and complex flavours throughout. Be aware of the interesting spicy kick in the last inch.Rating: [5 of 5 Stars!]
Date Added: Wednesday 31 December, 2014
wonderful cigar, a good smoke for any time of the day, i had this with a couple glasses of Balvenie 14yr Caribbean cask on New Years Eve, and i was in heaven... definitely a smooth smoke- i will be buying this again :)Rating: [5 of 5 Stars!]
Date Added: Tuesday 14 August, 2012
Top notch cigar, instantly became a personal favourite. Embodies what I like about the monte range, bold, savoury flavour with a hint of spice and earthiness. Rushed out for a couple more to lay down for a while. Good level of strength without being overpowering. Highly recommend these.Rating: [5 of 5 Stars!]
Date Added: Friday 10 December, 2010
Duncan's review tempted me to comment on the Edmundo. In my humble opinion it is one of the finest cigars Montecristo has ever produced .... but as many have already suggested it needs time to mature. Straight of a new box they give little in terms of flavour .... time in the humidor improves taste and burn dramatically and a little experimentation leads me to suggest that 20c and 70% are the magic numbers. Two years in they are fabulous ...Rating: [4 of 5 Stars!]