Customers generally find this Mitchellero Peru Robusto Extra to be an excellent value, offering a smooth, flavorful, and consistent smoke, especially for its price point. While many praise its reliable construction, draw, and burn, a few reviewers did encounter issues with uneven burning or a tight draw, suggesting some inconsistency in individual sticks.
Ideal for both new and experienced cigar smokers looking for a reliable, flavorful, and budget-friendly daily smoke, particularly those who appreciate medium-bodied profiles with earthy, woody, and creamy notes.
AI generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
✓
Value (18)
✓
Flavour (21)
✓
Construction (13)
—
Draw (12)
✓
Beginner Friendly (5)
—
Burn (19)
✓
Repeat Buy (12)
✓
Smoking Time (7)
by David on Tuesday 21 July, 2026
This cigar was picked for me by the team in the CGars Chester shop as a decent cigar to practice my cutting and lighting skills on as still a newbie to the scene.
I found it really easy to cut and lit really well, and I have to say for the price was a really pleasant smoke. Still working on my palate so can’t really comment on the flavours but wasn’t too strong or peppery, I did have to relight it a couple of times but that was probably more down to me talking. Plenty or smoke and a pleasant smell, would definitely buy a few to keep in the humidor as an every day smoke.
Great recommendation by the guys at CGars/Tumeraus Chester.
by Mark on Thursday 16 April, 2026
I asked the team at CGars to suprise me with a replacement cigar for the one I ordered which was no longer available.
Happy that they they sent this, a well constructed cigar with a good draw and burn.Definetley livens up towards the end, and lasted a good 55 minutes.For the price, I will certainly be buying some more once I get a bigger humidor....
by Adam on Monday 08 December, 2025
Nice hour plus medium smoke without any discernable flavour notes for me but a medium tobacco flavour that coated my mouth by the nub. Its flaw was burning unevenly at an angle from the end of first third all way down
by Martin on Friday 26 September, 2025
I was really looking forward to trying this cigar but the flavour profile just didn't do anything for me unfortunately.
It was a well constructed cigar, great even burn all the way till the end and a nice easy smooth draw also. So this isn't a negative review, just wasn't the right cigar for me.
by Richard on Wednesday 03 September, 2025
As someone still new to cigars, the Mitchellero Peru Robusto has been a real eye-opener for me. It’s described as an approachable, well-priced smoke, and I can see why it’s a favorite among beginners and more seasoned smokers alike. On the cold draw, I got hints of earth and a touch of cedar, nothing too heavy or intimidating. Once lit, it opened up with a very smooth profile—creamy at times, with light coffee and nutty notes. There’s a bit of pepper, but it doesn’t dominate; it just adds a little tingle that keeps things interesting. The construction was surprisingly solid for the price point—the draw was consistent, and the ash held on longer than I expected. By the halfway point, I noticed some leathery notes and a mild sweetness that reminded me of dried fruit, though very subtle. It’s not overly complex, but it doesn’t need to be; it’s just a straightforward, reliable cigar that delivers plenty of flavor without overwhelming a newcomer. I’d happily recommend this to anyone starting out or looking for an easy daily smoke. For me, this one feels like great value and enjoyable balance.
Rating: 8/10
