Customers generally find this 'Stumpy' cigar to be a surprisingly flavourful and satisfying short smoke, often praised for its rich, creamy, and earthy notes, especially considering its budget-friendly price. While many appreciate its solid construction and even burn, a notable number of reviewers experienced issues with the wrapper unraveling or an uneven burn, suggesting some inconsistency in quality.
Ideal for those seeking a full-flavoured, medium-strength cigar for a shorter smoking session, particularly if you appreciate earthy and creamy notes and are willing to overlook potential inconsistencies in wrapper construction.
AI generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
✓
Flavour (27)
✓
Value (14)
✓
Smoking Time (14)
✓
Draw (10)
✓
Beginner Friendly (3)
—
Burn (18)
—
Construction (18)
—
Appearance (6)
by Anthony on Sunday 02 August, 2026
Tried the Inka blue few days ago and was pleasantly pleased. Now then ,Mr Stumpy certainly feels solid.
Initial aroma cold was I thought earthy,and rich.
After decapping,the draw was snug but okay.
Overall look and construction was good,and no ragged edges when cutting. Once lit this stick was pushing out plentiful smoke without any help from me. The first half was giving lots of individual flavour notes which I failed to identify, however very enjoyable,and held till the middle. Now this cigar settled down,the flavours all married together and sweetly smooth, I tried to ash the first half ,incase it dropped, but it resisted and held on perfectly.Infact the ash looked silvery salt and pepper. I am a 30 /40 second drawer and noticed between draws the smoke bloom faded now till activated again.
Just after half way the cigar felt hot now holding it with thumb and finger,but taste was very satisfying.
No issues at all with wrapper ,Personally I'd rather have this in a half corona and smaller diameter providing the flavours remained the same.As with alot of cigars,the flavours come together at half way,and are worth the wait.Would I recommend, yes,but give it a chance to settle and marinate.
Will try the red next Cheers you cigar lovers.
by Anthony on Thursday 30 July, 2026
Cigars arrived today.Not tried yet.However the package arrived safety. The person at C Gars did a marvelous job of presenting my two budget cigars in the presentation box,which made them feel abit special. I also received the Cigar magazine, nice treat.This extra care ,just makes the buying experience more satisfying for both customers and retailers. I'm afraid to open the magazine incase I make another purchase,and have to catch postman outside before wife knows,Lol.
Thankyou very much for marvelous customer service, Highly recommended.
by James on Friday 12 June, 2026
The more I explore this blend the more I am enjoying it. This is a full Peruvian puro. Prelight is has a rich chocolate smell. Burn was a tad uneven put i think thats more the fact it was sitting at 71% before I lit up. Very smooth creamy smoke with a hint of pepper and a slightly spicy retro hale. For the price you really cant go wrong. Much nicer than other vitolas in this size
by ASHLEY on Wednesday 06 May, 2026
I mainly agree with the other positive reviews, as this is a nice, easy draw cigar ideal for one that burns very well and provides a good deal of smoke, andf they type of cigar you might smoke at the BBQ or outside beer garden. Downsides? Not really, I prefer a little tighter packing and perhaps a little less smoke at times but, but having said that, it is one I shall be buying again.
by Lee on Saturday 14 March, 2026
Nice Saturday afternoon smoke.
Nice even burn that only needed touching up once but thatwas probably down to my lighting up skills
Nice draw,good taste and plenty of smoke with a good aroma
Held ash very well (all the way to the end!!!)
Only complaint was the label took some getting off!!!
Smoked until it was getting to hot for my lips lol
Definitely buying more.