Montecristo No. 5 Cigar - Box of 10

Buy this item and earn 76 points valued at 0.76.

    50 Review(s)  |  Add Your Review


Please log in to use Fast Buy


Flavour: Medium to Full
Length: 4" (102mm)
Ring Gauge: 40 ring gauge
Packaging: Box of 10

Tasting Notes

It has all the qualities of the brand and is a real appetizer with its intense spicy flavour. It also has a certain sweetness, think chocolate mixed with raisins. Truly delicious.

Taste Test

Reviewed by Joe Gellman

I finished breakfast and had a half cup (we use the French cups, you know, the ones you use two hands to hold) of Cubita coffee left and decided to go to the terrace (actually, a deck over the garage where I do most of my smoking) and finish the coffee and smoke a No. 5.

The cigar measures 4" x 40 (mine measured 4" x 41 and though it has been described as having a ring gauge of 40 or 42, I find this to be part of the manner of storage. I will buy a few at the factory in Cuba next October and measure them to try my hypothesis) and is a mighty little might, when aged properly (as this was, thank you, C.GARS Ltd) I get a kick out of the oft overused tripe that this vitola is the brand's poorest make. Well, it that is true, all the vitolas are of my liking, the poorest still good enough for my tastes.

I found the cigar to be as full bodied as the No. 4 and a tad fuller than the No. 3 corona. It lit well and burned evenly to the last. This is a quick smoke, though I lingered with it and the last of the coffee for 25 minutes. As with the Joyitas, the ash was solid, medium to dark in colour, listing a tad to the right (well, there was a breeze and that might have affected the burn). I flicked the ash after 2 inches and felt it crunch under my finger. The smoke had woody and sweet overtones, reminiscent of a bouquet of wild flowers, gentle yet enough to stir the imagination. The smoke wafted slowly and formed a haze about the Apricot tree behind where I was sitting, and hung there until the gentle breeze swept it away.

I think this cigar was aged less than one year and had only a hint of oil, just showing itself enough to make the cigar a tad blotchy from this new emanation. The flavour did not grow through the entire length of the cigar until, that is, the last two puffs - then I noticed a very strong finish, akin to when you smell a rose but then get the full aroma when you stick your nose into the flesh of the petals.

While the cigar has been described as 'herbaceous', I did not find this supply to follow that note, but, rather, I think this selection had some light personality. I suspect that this supply was very well aged which lent to it's flavour and aroma. Once again the adage that age will mature a good cigar comes true.


(Current Reviews: 50)
Displaying 6 to 10 (of 50 reviews) Result Pages: [<< Prev]   1  2  3  4  5 ...  [Next >>] 
by Tomas Date Added: Wednesday 09 November, 2011
This is one of my favourite small sized, quick smokes. It has a very nice woody/nutty flavour with a hint of sweet and spicy notes. it has an easy draw and great burn that lasts for about 40 mins. Definitely a must-buy for any cigar smoker.

Rating: 5 of 5 Stars! [5 of 5 Stars!]
by Andy Date Added: Tuesday 02 August, 2011
One of my favourites when a quick smoke is the order of the day. Great with coffee and a few squares of nice dark chocolate which compliments the nice sweet flavour with a hint of cocoa. Typical Montecristo quality.

Rating: 5 of 5 Stars! [5 of 5 Stars!]
by Michael Date Added: Wednesday 27 April, 2011
Well it's quite simply a wonderful smoke.Construction and draw perfect and burn as near perfect as makes no difference,I just had to gently touch the wrapper down one side briefly after I lost the first ash.Fantastically cool and smooth smoking experience with a growing intensity of sweet and spicy as the cigar developed.Not terribly complex as you might expect for a 40 RG but as a go to everyday smoke when there's a spare 40 minutes to kick back with then these are very well worth it.

Rating: 4 of 5 Stars! [4 of 5 Stars!]
by Nathan Date Added: Sunday 17 May, 2009
Yeah, I think that this smoke has pretty much nailed the market for this price range. Long lasting, complex, well constructed, and certainly a cigar that inspires confidence. Strongly recommended to the cigar newcomer, and as a staple for more established smokers alike. There's a woodyness that works well with rum, and a spicy background tainted with brazil nut (I agree with the former reviewer that nut is definitely in there) that oscillates up and down throughout the 40 minutes of pleasure that this smoke brings. Buy one and enjoy it.

Rating: 4 of 5 Stars! [4 of 5 Stars!]
by Iain Date Added: Saturday 03 November, 2007
I thought that this was an exquisite smoke, a great size for when you are going out and it is a very smooth smoke with a hint of nuttiness and a little spice, do not be put off by the size its still a rather long smoke and definately one to try.

Rating: 4 of 5 Stars! [4 of 5 Stars!]
Displaying 6 to 10 (of 50 reviews) Result Pages: [<< Prev]   1  2  3  4  5 ...  [Next >>] 


  • Order Online or by Phone: 07000 088 088
  • Orders placed by 2pm are despatched the same day
  • Next Working Day Delivery Available at the checkout for orders placed by 2pm (excludes selected products that may require special delivery arrangements as per product notes)